|
Watauga Lake |
Sullen, gray, foreboding, lowering, threatening, ominous; today’s local sky.
I’ve restarted occasional emailing to some political cronies who live
on the west coast. When my friend Dave died last winter, I got out of
the habit of commenting on their thoughts and arguments. I did keep up
with their goings-on, though. Of course we discuss more than politics;
they must have found out that I am from the South and they began a
discussion saying the North would have been better off if they had
allowed the South to secede in 1860. I realize they were baiting me but
they grabbed the wrong bear by the ass this time. I am no history
expert, but I have extensively read, studied, and thought on the matters
of why the southern states left the Union and why the North–especially
Abraham Lincoln–
could not
allow it to happen for any reason or excuse. Following is part of my
reply; I kept it simple because, like I said, they are all west coast
men and really very ignorant of the South. They are all well educated
but have chosen to believe the southern stereotypes. They are all–less
one tea-partier–Obama-crats.
Me:
Had the South’s nullification and secession attempt
succeeded, it is my opinion as a Southerner that some of the wayward
states would soon have reapplied for admission back into the Union. My
home state of Tennessee may have been the first to do so; most of the
population of the eastern, mountain dominated section of the state were
die-hard Unionists. … It is my belief that the Confederacy would never
have held together and slavery would have died out as the
industrialization of the continent progressed.
>This is part of one of their quotes and my response:
They:
” … we would now be faced with huge numbers of marginally illiterate southerners flooding over our borders … .”
Me:
Easy to speculate here but hard to put a handle on in reality; time stands still for no man or nation. The
world was changing fast and the South would have been forced to keep up
or possibly fall into anarchy or come under heavy influence from
outside; they would not have had the money to keep up and I don’t think
the North would have allowed too much help for Dixie from outlanders.
I can think of many reasons why the nation had to remain united and
these guys have yet to show me why the states should have parted.
Enough of my drivel that no one is interested in anyway; have a great
weekend!